My wife is a Jimmy Buffet fan and I just like the whole island life theme. I’ve wanted to go to Cheeseburger in Paradise (having been to Margeritaville a few times while vacationing), but there are not many of them and the one closest to us is still a distance. But we happened to be in the area one weekend and we finally had the chance to go.
It certainly gives you the feeling of a being at seaside with the bright colors and Tiki huts. We got there early enough before the dinner crowd. And it was happy hour. We ordered a bucket of Buds. I couldn’t figure why they didn’t have Jimmy Buffet’s beer Landshark Lager or their special craft beer Paradise Beach Ale as part of happy hour, although they did serve them. The waitress didn’t know why. Speaking of the waitress, it must be fun to have a dress code that consists of a t-shirt and shorts (okay, maybe not in the winter).
We started with the Smugglers’ Platter; which consisted of Mini-Cheeseburgers, Dragon Fire Chicken Wings, and Fried Pickles.
First, the Mini-Cheeseburgers were the cutest and one of the best sliders that I have eaten. The Dragon Fire Chicken Wings were hot and tasty. Lastly, the Fried Pickles were crispy and much better than the Fried Pickles at Hooters.
Being a hamburger joint, we ordered hamburgers of course! I choose the:
BBQ Cheddar Burger
Cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, pickles, lettuce and fried onion strings, but opted for turkey instead of a beef burger. This was a big sandwich with a lot of crispy onion strings. I finished the burger but not the onion strings. The burger was tasty and not too overwhelming with the BBQ sauce.
My wife ordered the:
Powerhouse Burger
The great flavor from our buffalo wings is now available on a burger! Buffalo Asiago cheese, hot wing sauce, Blue Cheese dressing, tomato, red onion and lettuce. She couldn’t finish the burger and only ate half. She enjoyed it though. I ate the second half the following day and although I do not care for blue cheese it was still good. My wife ordered sweet potato chips with her order and they were rubbery, not crispy. Not good at all. And the menu states that they are made in house. Not a good sign.
Now my eyes are certainly bigger than my stomach and I had to try the:
Copa Banana
Fresh bananas, strawberries, toasted coconut, whipped cream, Nilla® wafers and banana pudding layered in our martini glass.
We shared it and it was everything I hoped it would be but by this time I was full and had to force myself to finish. I was ready to walk off my dinner!
All in all it was a good meal in a nice restaurant. Too bad it wasn’t closer to home. I would go there more often. I give it a 4 out of 5.
Next one I want to try is Sonic Drive-In. Any thoughts on that?